Benefit Birthday Suit & Skinny Jeans Deliver the Creaseless Cream Shadow/Liner Promise!

Besides bolder lip shades, something else that I unexpectedly fell in love with this year has to be cream eyeshadows. In the past I was skeptical: how can anything stay put on my normal-to-oily monolids? Well, as it turned out, some cream shadows deliver the creaseless promise, like Benefit Creaseless Cream Shadow/Liner! Today I’m showing you Birthday Suit and Skinny Jeans.

The Creaseless Cream Shadow comes in a glass pot with doves on the cap. Each pot contains 4.5 grams (0.16 oz), which is a bit more generous than comparable product on the market.

I initially received Skinny Jeans from a friend (my blogger girl Teri at BellaChique. She’s down with a flu at the moment, so drop by and show her some love!). Despite the fact that I love the formula and color to bits, I wasn’t going to review it because whatever can be said has already been said since these were launched several years ago. However, when I liked the formula enough to purchase Birthday Suit, I thought they deserve to be mentioned!

(This also justifies the fact that the I dipped my finger in the pot of Skinny Jeans before I photographed it)

Skinny Jeans is a grayed-out shimmery pewter-khaki on me. When I saw the line-up I knew that if I could have ONE shade, Skinny Jeans had to be it. It is amazingly complex, great for smokey looks, and goes well with many shades in my stash.

Birthday Suit is a shimmery beige on me. I know that it might not seem exciting, but if every leading lady needs a good supporting actress, Birthday Suit could be anyone’s supporting actress! You can use it as a light wash on the lids for something very understated and natural, or as a base with other eyeshadows on
top! In the picture above, I have it all over my lids with some soft contouring to bring light to my eyes without stealing the thunder of my lips (Rouge d’Armani #408)!

Here is the swatch. From bottom to top: Birthday Suit sheered out, Birthday Suit swatched heavily, Skinny Jeans sheered out, Skinny Jeans swatched heavily.

The formula of these cream shadows is excellent. Even if I really sheer them out, there wouldn’t be any patchiness. On top of that, it is easy to build the color up. Benefit suggests doing thin layers, and leaving 30 seconds between layers.

Tip: There is always a good possibility that your cream shadows crease on you simply because the formula doesn’t work for you, but even a good formula could crease if you slather it on. It’s much easier for them to stay put if the layers are thin!

Even with no primer underneath, Benefit Creaseless Cream Shadows hold up throughout the day for me. At the end of the day, the edges would oxidize a little (because my lids do get a bit oily), but there is no unsightly creasing or even disappearing from the inner corners. On top of a primer, these babies are invincible! If I have a long day ahead of me and I want to look presentable, I’d definitely pull these out!

This is me with Skinny Jeans all over my lids with Bobbi Brown Rich Caviar palette on top:

Bottom line: If you like any of the shades Benefit Creaseless Cream Shadow/Liner offers, I’d encourage you to pick it up. I can recommend the formula from my personal experience, and the general feedback seems positive. Remember to use thin layers to further reduce the chance of creasing, and I hope these will last on you as well as they last on me!

Have you tried any Benefit Creaseless Cream Shadow/Liner? How do you like it? Are there any cream shadows you think I should try?

Sunny, your beauty culture translator xx



  • Shoegal

    Looks nice! So did you use skinny jeans to line your eyes as well?

    • http://mostlysunnybunny.wordpress.com Sunny

      Thanks girl! Yes I have lined my lower lash line with Skinny Jeans. It works well too!

  • http://www.nailsandcupcakes.com Isabelle

    I got a dark grey one years ago and I fell in love with it instantly. It also makes for such a good last minute solution when your evening nap took you way too long and you’re forced to rush to get ready to make it to your party in time! It has now dried up completely though and I tossed it away. So sad :(

    • http://mostlysunnybunny.wordpress.com Sunny

      Aww that’s sad. You have reminded me that I have to use mine as often as I can before they dry out!

  • http://www.valleydollbeautyblog.blogspot.com ValleyDoll

    Skinny jeans is gorgeous !

    • http://mostlysunnybunny.wordpress.com Sunny

      I agree! It’s an easy smokey eye in a pot!

  • http://eyemasq.wordpress.com ShannonBearzatto

    I’ve never tried any of these before despite their being around for some time. I will have to check them out next time I’m at Sephora looking for a little something something! Thanks for the great post Sunny – as usual you look gorgeous!

    • http://mostlysunnybunny.wordpress.com Sunny

      Thanks Shannon! Do check these out. The formula works well for me!

  • http://www.bellachique.be/ Teri

    Aaaaw, thanks for the love hon! I’ve seen Skinny Jeans on you and you really rock that shade! Cream es are so awesome for layering, so much fun eh :)

    • http://mostlysunnybunny.wordpress.com Sunny

      Mwahaha you’re welcome Teri! I honestly didn’t see the point of layering in the beginning, but now it literally opens a new door for me!

  • http://www.peggytimmermans.be/blog Peggy Timmermans Visagie

    As much as i like them…unfortunately i caan’t do cream eyeshadows..they crease always even with primer.

    • http://mostlysunnybunny.wordpress.com Sunny

      Aww that’s unfortunate! You never know though. With all the new technology, maybe one day a brand will come up with something you can wear!

  • http://bronzerbunny.com Joyce (bronzerbunny)

    Ooh these look good on you! I always sort of look at these at sephora haha. I just don’t know if there’s a shade for me!

    • http://mostlysunnybunny.wordpress.com Sunny

      Do take a look at Birthday Suit. As you can see it’s a very everyday type of shade that isn’t overwhelming sparkling!

  • http://twitter.com/BeautyReflectTS BeautyReflections (@BeautyReflectTS)

    I love these as well! They actually last quite well on my really oily lids. Better than most other kinds!

    • http://mostlysunnybunny.wordpress.com Sunny

      Yup that’s what I think as well!

  • http://www.memoiselle.com Memoiselle

    I have Benefit Creaseless shadow in Tattle Tale. It works fine with me for about 4 hours but after that it start to crease because my lids are tend to be oily. I love the color range of this eyeshadow but I still love Eyes to Kill better :)

    • http://mostlysunnybunny.wordpress.com Sunny

      Doh too bad it doesn’t work for you! I love Eyes to Kill with all my heart, but they are very sparkling so they’re not really the same with these!